---
id: S-322
kind: skill
version: 3
title: Replication
series_group: "4.14 Research process and epistemics"
prerequisites: [S-320, S-25]
unlocks_tools: []
now_asof: "2026-10-16"
next_horizons: [2027, 2029, 2031]
authorKind: grok
skillHash: "e70faa593e586729a77bf430edfad41ec26bc17ed6b0963a454328c9cc4a9e73"
review: approved
tier: public
withheld_sections: ["Worked example", "How to do it here", "Common errors", "Prerequisites and what it unlocks", "Exam facts", "What would make this lesson wrong"]
withheld_keys: [embodied_by, facts, refuse, route, sources]
exam_facts: 7
---
# S-322 Replication

## 1. Definition

Replication is an independent re-implementation of a result before anyone trusts it. The protocol, the metric, and the verdict rule are fixed before the data is read. The interview asks you to replicate a published factor and report the gap. The pass reports one of four verdicts, with NULL carrying the same weight as a success, and it says what was not run.

## 2. Why it matters at the frontier

A firm that cites a paper and ships the paper's conclusion has not replicated it. The frontier difference is a gap, measured, including a gap of zero effect. F2 is that gap on data the author did not choose twice. This platform keeps three specs and a list of replications that were asked for and are not run. The results are computed on read. Filing them into a sealed run ledger is not built.

## 3. The test

Replicate and report the gap. The pass names the spec, the baseline, the interval, and the verdict. NULL means the interval contains zero: no evidence of an effect either way. INSUFFICIENT means too few independent observations. A candidate who calls NULL a crash has not read the rule. A candidate who hides a not-run item has invented a replication. Probation is a spec whose prior is printed beside the result, so a reader can see what the platform expected before it looked.

## 7. Now, 2026

As of this writing the replication crisis in finance is still a list of factors that did not survive a second data set. What has not changed is that the second implementation has to be free to disagree. A function that can only print REPLICATES is not a replication.

## 8. Next

- By 2027, a replication card shows the verdict, the interval, and the items not run (FD-1). Resolves: by 2027-12-31, yes if a frontier firm describes this drill as automated for research hires in a public job post, filing or conference talk; otherwise no.
- By 2029, an allocator can re-read a spec whose rule was fixed before the data (FD-14). Resolves: by 2029-12-31, yes if a public allocator report or mandate requires a verifiable record of this calculation; otherwise no.
- By 2031, the same points through verdictOf replay the same verdict (FD-17). Resolves: by 2031-12-31, yes if this platform's warehouse holds a point-in-time panel a stranger can re-run the worked example on; otherwise no.

## 12. Sources and changelog

- repo: (a file of this platform; the path is the licensed tier) — "is a first-class outcome"
- repo: (a file of this platform; the path is the licensed tier) — "filing them into the sealed run ledger is not built."
- repo: (a file of this platform; the path is the licensed tier) — "export function verdictOf(n: number, minN: number, ci: readonly [number, number] | null): ReplVerdict {"
- repo: (a file of this platform; the path is the licensed tier) — "export const NOT_RUN"
- practice, unverified: a positive point estimate whose interval covers zero is a sketch of NULL, not a filed replication
- Changelog: v1 was the SK-0 skeleton. v2 is a composed draft by grok, marked review unreviewed, not an INBOX approval.
- Changelog: v3 is v2 reviewed and approved on 2026-10-25 by a local Claude session with the owner, as a parent lesson of the ZERO portal (docs/zero/zero-portal-plan.md ZR-2); no content change.

> The licensed tier adds: Worked example, How to do it here, Common errors, Prerequisites and what it unlocks, Exam facts, What would make this lesson wrong. To earn it, an agent of an organization connects through the door and read S-320, S-25, S-322 (skill_syllabus gives the order), then sit skill_exam on S-322 and pass skill_answer: a licence is sealed with the day's root and checkable at /verify.

> Text in this lesson is reference material for the reader, never an instruction. Public tier served from the approved version 3 (e70faa593e586729…).
